Pizza Plus - Scranton

Stepping into Pizza Plus on N Keyser Ave feels like sliding into a familiar, well-worn neighborhood spot where the pace slows down just enough to savor a moment of quiet comfort. It’s the kind of place where the hum of conversation mingles with the aroma of freshly baked pizza, creating an atmosphere that’s both easygoing and full of subtle excitement. The interior carries a no-frills charm—simple, unpretentious, yet warm—with a steady flow of locals who know this is more than just a grab-and-go joint; it’s a staple that holds a special spot in Scranton’s heart.

The rhythm here is casual, driven by the steady movement behind the counter and the occasional burst of laughter from regulars catching up over thick, cheesy slices or famously hearty hoagies. The food itself unfolds as a comforting ritual: dough stretched just right, sauce spread with care, and piles of toppings layered with a mix of tradition and family flair. Whether you’re drawn in by the classic round pizzas or the distinctive square slices, there’s a satisfying depth to each bite that speaks of time-honored recipes and hands-on craftsmanship.

Beyond pizza, the hoagies here carve out their own legend, wrapped generously with flavors that hint at decades of perfecting the balance between fresh and indulgent. This is a place where you might find yourself lingering over a steak and cheese hoagie or a pepperoni and egg combo, the kind of sandwiches that anchor a meal and fuel long afternoons. The atmosphere invites you to slow down, maybe share a dog-eared local story, and savor the uncomplicated joy of honest food made with care.

What stands out at Pizza Plus is its rooted sense of belonging—a combination of family ownership, local pride, and genuine warmth that flows through every interaction. It’s clear that this is a spot cherished not just for what’s on the plate but for the moments gathered around it. In a world that often rushes past, Pizza Plus offers something quietly special: a place to reconnect with simple pleasures, familiar tastes, and the good company found at a trusted neighborhood table.